"The problem is, that when you attempt to coordinate the schedules, you back into March," Fehr said Thursday. "On balance you look it and go, 'Well, whatever its benefits would be in terms of some calendar association, it really doesn't work.' ... It's impossible, I think, to do it any other time next time than in March."Looks like Selig is going to get his way on this one. As I mentioned last year, though, I strongly disagree with this assessment. March is an awful time to hold the Classic. Major league players are rusty, managers treat it as spring training, and injuries, should they happen, are almost certain to impact the regular season.
The alternative, as I see it, is to hold it following the World Series, starting the first or second week of November. Benefits:
- Most players would receive a month off prior to the classic to recover from the regular season, yet wouldn't be off so long that they'd get rusty.
- Injuries, should they happen, would be more likely to have healed prior to the start of the next season.
- Managers wouldn't be under pressure to get stars into shape for the regular season, so they could just focus on winning.
- It doesn't require interrupting any standard major league activities. Period.
Even if the do normally take November off, I don't see why they can't keep throwing. Half the teams only play in the first round anyway, so they'd be done in a week's time. Worst case scenario, they have to take December off and then start throwing in January. It might effect the subsequent regular season, though I doubt it would effect it more than interrupting spring training would.
ReplyDeleteI do see your point about the marketing issue, though, and it's a very good point. In fact, I bet it's the #1 reason they're going for March over November. Hmph. I guess the only other option would be to hold it during the All-Star break. Not something I'd mind, but I can see that encountering a lot more resistance. ...
I'd still lean toward a November competition, but I acknowledge that money is everything in this sort of venture.
Humbug. -j